LoginSubscribe Now
International In-house Counsel Journal Logo
International In-house Counsel Journal Logo
  • Home
  • Business Sectors
  • Areas of Law
  • Editorial Board
  • Write a Paper
  • Subscribe
  • Books
  • Reports
  • Back Issues
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • PLS LogoCopyright & permissions
© 2026 International In-house Counsel Journal Ltd. | ISSN 1754-0607 | Picture Credits: Freepix, Unsplash and by permission of the authors
Back to library search

A Gold Standard for Clean Room Development to Protect From Intellectual Property Infections

November 2023Intellectual PropertyGeneral

Abstract

In many situations, a company encounters intellectual property that it cannot allow to spread to a product in development. One example is a joint development project between two companies where the IP for the jointly developed product cannot seep into other products. Another example is where two parties have a business relationship where they exchange products, but one party decides to terminate the relationship and design a replacement for the other party’s product. Yet another example is where one company is found to have misappropriated another company’s IP and, after litigation, is required by the court to redesign its product without utilizing any of the misappropriated IP. I will call the IP at issue “infection IP” because, like a disease in a human body, it cannot be allowed to spread within the company and certainly not to a new product. Ultimately the point of clean room development is to eliminate any infection IP or, in other words, reduce the chances of being sued and increase the chances of surviving any such litigation.

Subscribe to reador
PLS Logo Copyright & permissions

Author

Bob Zeidman

President, Zeidman Consulting, USA

Related Papers

Who Owns the Innovation? IP Title, Start-Up Formation Failures, and the Hidden Cost of Defective Ownership in Investment and Exit Transactions
For in-house counsel advising start-ups, intellectual property is often the principal source of value. Software, technical know-how, inventions, brands, data, content and confidential processes may be more important than physical...Read more
Portrait image of Madelein Kleyn
Madelein Kleyn
CEO, Mad K IP Consulting (Pty) Ltd, South Africa
AI and IP Strategy – The On-Going Transformation of Innovation and Value Creation
This article is based on the panel discussion “IP Strategy and AI – Industry Perspective,” which Sonja London moderated at the Helsinki IP Summit 2025. The discussion brought together IP...Read more
Portrait image of Pirke Fustinoni
Pirke Fustinoni
Vice President IP & Tech Legal, Metso Corporation, Finland
Portrait image of Sonja London
Sonja London
Founder, Advisor, Fearless IP, Finland
Portrait image of Mika Timmerbacka
Mika Timmerbacka
Director of Intellectual Property, UPM-Kymmene, Finland
Portrait image of Heidi Adler
Heidi Adler
Director, Intellectual Property Rights, ORION Corporation, Finland
The Interplay between Antitrust Law and Intellectual Property Law in South Africa: A Critical Analysis of the OECD Recommendation on Intellectual Property Rights and Competition
The interplay between competition law and intellectual property remains the subject of much debate. Intellectual property creates monopolistic rights to protect and reward innovation and incentivise creators; whilst competition law...Read more
Portrait image of Madelein Kleyn
Madelein Kleyn
CEO, Mad K IP Consulting (Pty) Ltd, South Africa
Portrait image of Michael Currie
Michael Currie
Partner, Primerio, South Africa
Portrait image of Stephany Torres
Stephany Torres
Senior Associate, Primerio, South Africa
Portrait image of Joshua Eveleigh
Joshua Eveleigh
Associate (designate), Primerio, South Africa
Patent law differs in each country, but there are some important equitable doctrines that apply across borders. One such a doctrine is prosecution history estoppel. The term Estoppel ...Read more
Portrait image of Roy Girasa
Roy Girasa
Professor of Law, Pace University, USA
Portrait image of Madelein Kleyn
Madelein Kleyn
CEO, Mad K IP Consulting (Pty) Ltd, South Africa
Portrait image of Mark McCareins
Mark McCareins
General Counsel, Metals Service Center Institute, USA
Portrait image of Shafaq Akhtar
Shafaq Akhtar
Other, University of Law, UK